Turtle's Restaurant

Turtle's on Little Sarasota Bay at 8875 Midnight Pass Road has been serving waterfront seafood and American classics since 1986, earning a loyal following for its bay views, generous portions, and consistent kitchen. Baked stuffed shrimp, coconut-crusted shrimp, grouper, mahi-mahi, and prime rib anchor the menu, with an early bird dinner available from opening and a Sunday brunch from 10am–1pm. The all-day menu, 365-day schedule, and accessible pricing make Turtle's the most dependable waterfront dining option on the southern end of Siesta Key — a low-key local landmark that never disappoints.