Clayton's Siesta Grille

American | Siesta Key, FL | $$$$

1256 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA


Overview

Clayton's Siesta Grille at 1256 Old Stickney Point Road has earned the 'venerable institution' label that its Facebook page claims — Chef Dimitri Xinidis has been turning out fresh Gulf grouper, salmon, trout almondine, crispy duck, filet mignon, fish tacos, and pizzas with a kitchen that makes everything — every sauce, every soup, every dessert — from scratch. The catering operation runs alongside the restaurant, handling private events of any size. Open every evening from 4pm, with late service on Fridays and Saturdays. A dining room that rewards loyalty and hasn't needed a gimmick to stay relevant for decades.

Cuisine: American

Atmosphere: Established dinner house on Old Stickney Point Rd

Mains: $22 - $44
Dress Code: Smart Casual

Inhaven Insights

  • What's great

    What's great

    Trout Almondine

    Grouper, trout almondine, and crispy duck made nightly by Chef Dimitri — scratch cooking throughout.

  • What's unique

    What's unique

    Scratch Kitchen

    Every sauce, soup, and dessert made from scratch in-house — no shortcuts at a Siesta institution.

  • What's worth knowing

    What's worth knowing

    Catering Available

    Full catering services for private events of any size — from beach picnics to formal receptions.

Similar Options

Popular Itineraries Nearby

Popular Stays in Siesta Key , FL