Crazy Susan’s Cookie Company

Bakery | Ocean City, NJ | $$$$

1345 West Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226


Overview

Susan Adair's cookies were always the first to vanish from family sweet tables, so in July 2006 she opened Crazy Susan's at 1345 West Avenue, a little yellow storefront on the bayside of town. Everything is baked to order and wrapped individually, and the list runs past 40 flavors: the Crazy Turtle, chocolate chip dipped in dark, milk or white, Pumpkindoodle, Peanut Butter Fluff, Oatmeal Cherry Coconut, the Mayor's Cookie and a rotating Cookie of the Month. Tins of 8 to 36 ship UPS, gluten-free versions come by phone, and the cookies also fill Johnny B Goode's ice cream sandwiches. Hours are not posted, so call before you drive over.

Cuisine: Bakery

Atmosphere: Little yellow cookie shop with a red awning

Mains: $35 - $48
Dress Code: Casual

Inhaven Insights

  • What's great

    What's great

    Forty-Plus Flavors

    Crazy Turtle, Pumpkindoodle, Peanut Butter Fluff, the Mayor's Cookie and chocolate-dipped chip.

  • What's unique

    What's unique

    Named at a Party

    A cousin's 'Who made the cookies? Crazy Susan?' named the shop, which Susan dedicated to cousin Joy.

  • What's worth knowing

    What's worth knowing

    Call for Hours

    No hours are posted online; call (609) 391-1919. Cookies contain peanuts, tree nuts, wheat and eggs.

Similar Options

Popular Itineraries Nearby

Popular Stays in Ocean City , NJ