Abel's Ice Cream

Cafe | Siesta Key, FL | $$$$

1886 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA


Overview

Abel's Ice Cream at 1886 Stickney Point Road in Southbridge Plaza has held TripAdvisor's number one dessert ranking in Sarasota for over twelve consecutive years, built on a rotation of 40-plus Florida-made hard-packed flavors alongside dairy-free sorbets, plant-based non-dairy options, and gluten-free choices. Flavors range from banana, butterscotch, and maple walnut to the house-favorite Toasted Coconut, Creamy Praline, and Salty Turtles. Owner Jerry and his team source from Florida-based creameries committed to quality over volume. Open daily at noon through evening — the natural cap to a Siesta Key beach day.

Cuisine: Cafe

Atmosphere: Beloved ice cream shop in Southbridge Plaza

Mains: $4 - $10
Dress Code: Casual

Inhaven Insights

  • What's great

    What's great

    12 Years at #1

    TripAdvisor's #1 dessert in Sarasota for over twelve consecutive years — a hard record to argue.

  • What's unique

    What's unique

    Florida-Made Cream

    All 40-plus flavors sourced from Florida-based creameries — local ice cream, not a national brand.

  • What's worth knowing

    What's worth knowing

    Opens at Noon

    Opens at noon daily — plan your beach day to end here before the evening crowd arrives.

Similar Options

Popular Itineraries Nearby

Popular Stays in Siesta Key , FL